|   | 
        
          
              | 
           
          
              | 
           
          
              | 
           
          
            | Comment on this report, or find other reports. | 
           
          
              | 
           
          
            | Our Mystery Worshippers are volunteers who warm church pews for us around the world. If you'd like to become a Mystery Worshipper, start here. | 
           
          
              | 
           
          
            | Find out how to reproduce this report in your church magazine or website. | 
           
                    | 
          | 
        
            
              
                
                  | 2344: Church 
                    of the Redeemer, Toronto, Canada | 
                 
                
                    | 
                 
                
                    
Photo: 
© Gary J. Wood and used under license
 | 
                 
                
                    | 
                 
                
                  Mystery 
                    Worshipper: Sparrow. 
                    The church: Church 
                    of the Redeemer, Toronto, Canada. 
                    Denomination: Anglican Church 
                    of Canada, Diocese 
                    of Toronto. 
                    The building: Completed in 1879, it is in the Gothic Revival style. A major 
                    renovation project was launched in the early 1980s, financed 
                    by proceeds from the sale of church lands to a hotel chain. 
                    There are three large stained-glass windows behind the altar 
                    depicting key moments in the life of Jesus and his disciples. 
                    The church: The church is lesbian/gay/bisexual/transgender friendly. It 
                    also has an "open door" policy: passers-by can stop in for 
                    prayer or a quiet moment of contemplation –  an especially 
                    useful provision given the building's location at a busy downtown 
                    intersection. 
                    The neighbourhood: The church is situated at the corner of Bloor Street and Avenue 
                    Road, sandwiched between the University of Toronto and the 
                    posh Yorkville shopping district, and just a stone's throw 
                    away from Queen's Park. It is also just a short walk from 
                    any of three subway stations: St George, Bay, and Museum. 
                    The cast: The Revd Canon Andrew J. Asbil, incumbent. 
                  The date & time: Ash Wednesday, February 22, 2012, 6:00pm. 
                   
                  What was the
name of the service? 
Sung Eucharist with Imposition of Ashes. 
                   
                    How full was the building? 
                    About half full, or around 150 people, comprising a mix of 
                    university students, young professionals, middle-agers, and 
                    grey hairs (the capacity is 300). The dress was mostly casual, 
                    except for a few "suits" who probably came straight 
                    from work. 
                     
                    Did anyone welcome you 
                    personally? 
                    I was silently handed a service leaflet and the Book of Common Praise by a greeter as I walked 
                    in. Later, as we exited the church, Canon Asbil personally 
                    thanked everyone for coming and shook everyone's hand. I also 
                    shook hands with five or six people during the passing of 
                    the peace, but no one in the congregation tried to make conversation 
                    with me then or at any other point. 
                   
                  Was your pew
comfortable? 
                    The front part of the church had pews, and several rows of 
                    wooden chairs were added in the back, some cushioned and some 
                    not. I'm not sure whether these chairs are normally out or 
                    if they were added as additional seating for the Ash Wednesday 
                    service. The chairs were fine, but there was nowhere to kneel 
                    during the prayer. Most people just bowed their heads. 
                   
                  How would you
describe the pre-service
atmosphere? 
Still as the night. Most people were sitting by themselves, silently
meditating or looking over the order of service. The few who came with
someone else were whispering quiet conversations to their friend or
partner beside them. There was no pre-service music. 
                   
                  What were the
exact opening words of the
service? 
"The Lord be with you." 
                   
                  What books did
the congregation use during the
service? 
A leaflet containing the order of service, based on the Book of Alternative Services, and
the Book of Common Praise. 
                   
                  What musical
instruments were played? 
There were both an organist and a choir. 
                   
                  Did anything
distract you? 
                    Smack in the middle of the service, a middle-aged woman with 
                    flaming red hair and large costume jewelry walked in late 
                    and headed straight down the centre aisle to a pew at the 
                    front of the church. Three or four people also ducked out 
                    right after taking their communion. I can only hope that these 
                    are the "Christmas and Easter only" type of church-goers, 
                    rather than their regulars. 
                   
                  Was the worship
stiff-upper-lip, happy clappy, or
what? 
                    We sang traditional Anglican liturgy from the Book of Common Praise, led by the choir and 
                    accompanied on organ. The choir was quite good, especially 
                    the soloists, but the organist was almost resistant to playing 
                    the music in time, which was confusing when I was trying to 
                    sing along with the hymns. Since it was an Ash Wednesday service, 
                    the congregation approached the altar rail not once but twice: 
                    the first time to receive the Sign of the Cross marked with 
                    black ashes on each person's forehead, and the second time 
                    to take communion. On a personal note, one of the hymns was 
                    "When I survey the wondrous cross," which was sung to the 
                    tune of Rockingham, but I much prefer the Lowell Mason 
                    version. 
                   
                  Exactly how
long was the sermon? 
8 minutes. 
                   
                    On a scale of 1-10, 
                    how good was the preacher? 
                    7 – The sermon was necessarily broad, given that it 
                    was an Ash Wednesday service. Canon Asbil's voice was almost 
                    completely flat, but somehow it didn't make my mind wander; 
                    rather, it drew me in and helped me to focus on his message, 
                    rather than his delivery. 
                     
                    In a nutshell, what 
                    was the sermon about? 
                    Canon Asbil started with a personal anecdote about watching 
                    divers practicing their technique at a pool. He used this 
                    story as an entry-point for talking about spiritual discipline 
                    during Lent. There was no one take-home point from his sermon, 
                    but rather a broad array of points about the importance of 
                    Lent. Lent as a call to self-examination, penitence, prayer, 
                    fasting, and alms-giving. The sermon emphasized the importance 
                    of discipline through the Lenten season and the need to support 
                    each other as a community during this time. 
                     
                    Which part of the service 
                    was like being in heaven? 
                    Taking communion to the sound of the choir singing "Jesus, 
                    remember me." The hymn itself is quite simple, but the choir 
                    gave a beautiful rendering that helped me to reflect on the 
                    meaning of the ritual. 
                   
                  And which part
was like being in... er... the other place? 
The communion wine was taken from a common cup; no individual plastic
cups were offered. Just the thought of all the lips that have touched
that cup makes me shudder. 
                   
                  What happened
when you hung around after the service looking lost? 
                    Canon Asbil greeted everyone personally on the way out. He 
                    thanked me for coming to the service but didn't try to make 
                    any conversation beyond that. Several groups of regulars were 
                    chatting with each other at the back of the church, but no 
                    one came to talk to me. Most people just headed straight out 
                    the door, since there was no after-service coffee, and it 
                    was dinnertime by then anyway. 
                   
                  How would you
describe the after-service
coffee? 
There was none. 
                   
                  How would you
feel about making this church your regular (where 10 = ecstatic, 0 =
terminal)? 
                    6 – Personally, I found the formality of the service 
                    too emotionally distancing for me to want to make this my 
                    regular church. However, Canon Asbil was a great draw. He's 
                    a compelling speaker, and I would be interested to hear him 
                    again in a regular weekly sermon, which would perhaps be more 
                    focused in content. 
                   
                  Did the service
make you feel glad to be a
Christian? 
                    Sure. Not in any particular way, but I'm also just glad when 
                    a church doesn't do or say anything horribly offensive. The 
                    community seemed very open and inclusive. 
                   
                  What one thing
will you remember about all this in seven days' time? 
                    Walking out of the church onto Bloor Street and seeing other 
                    people with a cross of ashes on their forehead. It made me 
                    feel that the Christian community is not just limited to the 
                    walls of the church, but in the rest of our lives as well. | 
                 
              
             
 | 
          | 
        
          
              | 
           
          
              | 
           
          
              | 
           
          
            | We rely on voluntary donations to stay online. If you're a regular visitor to Ship of Fools, please consider supporting us. | 
           
          
          
          
              | 
           
          
          
              | 
           
          
              | 
           
          
            | The Mystery Pilgrim | 
           
          
              | 
           
          
            |  One of our most seasoned reporters makes the Camino pilgrimage to Santiago de Compostela in Spain. Read here. | 
           
          
              | 
           
          
              | 
           
          
              | 
           
          
            | London churches | 
           
          
              | 
           
          
            |  Read reports from 70 London churches, visited by a small army of Mystery Worshippers on one single Sunday. Read here.  | 
           
          
            |   | 
           
          
          | 
          | 
         | 
          |